I would choose Plymouth because, they went there for the freedom not for the money. They had a good relationship with the indians which is great so you         will not get killed by them. Plymouth grew in size making them the largest colony and i would not want to be the one that did not get recognised. Yes they did have a difficult winter, but most of them survived. They started with men women and children which was smart because then they could grow their colony. They had Squanto show them how to survive so they did not starve. The Pilgrims wanted to give thanks to Squanto so they had a giant meal that is now celebrated and called Thanksgiving. They named it Plymouth due to the first rock that they stepped on when they arrived.  The Pilgrims wrote The Mayflower Contract that agreed that they should have fair laws they would stick together and everybody would agree to these laws.  An indian named Samoset welcomed the pilgrims. Squanto also helped the pilgrims make a peace treaty with the indians. And it became the largest city for over 100 years.